And… I’m spent.
Here’s my entry in Livia Blackburne’s Alternate Version Blogfest. Livia had tweeted about it nearly a month ago, but until yesterday I was coy about signing up. I knew trying a different writing style would be a worthwhile writing exercise, but I had a case of write-fright. Operative word: “had.”
Check it out!
First off, the original passage. It’s a short flashback from my work-in-progress, a YA eco-dystopian social sci-fi:
After a rehearsal months ago, when Ben and me were the last stragglers, Mr. Campo’s deft fingers fluttered in romantic sweeps up and down the keys. The tuner had just visited that day, like hundreds of times before. Her handiwork didn’t need testing. The song wasn’t one we were working on. Campo didn’t smile or wink while he played, but his exaggerated movements and uncharacteristic sound gave his goofing around away. Like someone with no life, he was poking fun at my crush. I couldn’t flee the room fast enough, feeling an intense blush rise to my face like one of those mercury thermometers.
Now, I’ll try a bit of an older style. Lit lovers, can you tell me which author I’m attempting to channel?:
I was struck by two keys, among a sounding board rung at times by the most fiery of passions; two keys which, though ceremoniously un-Thelonious-Monk-like (were they so, they would have been followed by an awkward pause in which the listener is meant to reflect on his interpretation of their musicality), they had a tinkling almost innate in their lightest pressing, triggering an entirely disproportionate reverberation in my foggy, hormone-addled head. The notes, whether the shift from one to the other, or the other to one, stopped time; with the g-force of a screeching halt before ratcheting back and gunning it in reverse to some moment formerly trapped in some deep cerebellar hiding-place. But no; how could it have been buried so far from previous reach? The moment, suddenly present and playing out in my mind’s eye, occurred only a few months ago.
The sound called forth another Tuesday afternoon entirely, when my choir director Mr. Campo worked his hands along the keys (as he often has occasion: at the ends of rehearsals, in a cutesy ditty hearkening to a “that’s the end of the show” wrap-up, or hands spanning octave-wide chords in vibrato: fabricated melodrama for laughter’s sake). No, this was the sound of mocking; of lilting fingers bringing to life the romantic interlude of which I daydream daily, the one pairing me with Ben (the boy who stands to my right, who laughs and smiles in all the best ways, at all the best times, like someone with whom I could sit and enjoy a cup of lime-flower tea when we’re 80). Throughout such an ignoble display of disrespect for young love, or at least infatuation, Campo’s hair waved around on his bobbing head with a not unnoticeable extra length; a common occurrence for the man. Like a tiny animal only hopping around on his cue, its waving added an absurdist dimension to the ridicule, only insult to injury since I normally enjoy the humor in such things. Albeit, there was some tiny comfort in imagining that while he was mocking me, his own hair was mocking himself. Still, what right does this man have (though he may know me well enough to read my every nonverbal cue, whether obvious or less so) to make such a comment with such facility as the sweeping, ironically weeping runs up and down those scales as if it were mere sport?
Ahhhh. That was oddly refreshing, probably because I’m quite think-y myself. (Maybe I’d like to be a brain scientist like Livia.)
Can you venture a guess at the author? Hint: using a flashback lent itself to a well-known excerpt of his.
Please drop your best guess in a comment below!
Hey, Chicago: First correct guess wins a free ticket to James Kennedy’s Dome of Doom (Order of Odd-Fish art show and battle-dance tournament at Chicago’s Collaboraction – Saturday night, April 17)!
Add to: Facebook | Digg | Del.icio.us | Stumbleupon | Reddit | Blinklist | Twitter | Technorati | Yahoo Buzz | Newsvine
Hehe, well, you already told me. But since I’ve never read him, I wouldn’t have guessed. Hmm, maybe I’ll have to go check him out. Thanks for particpating, despite the chattering teeth :-)
If you can believe it, I hadn’t read him before Wednesday. I’d meant to for a while – glad I finally did!
Wow, that was quite the change-up! Great job at rewriting the scene in a completely different style. And very well, I might add! The style does seem very familiar, but I can’t quite place it.
Thanks, Steph! Yeah, it’s a little esoteric. (I may not have guessed it either, actually.)
Margo, thanks for your comment over on my blog :)
I love your literary version – I am tempted to say that the style is very Nabokov, but the fact you said it was especially suited to a flashback makes me think it might be Proust. I’ve never read Proust but I know he’s very big on stuff in the past!
If you don’t want to give the game away here, please pop over to my blog and let me know the right answer!
Hey Ellen, thought I’d go ahead and post your comment. Thanks so much for visiting, you smarty. You should read him sometime, there are some nice passages.
(Thanks for being understanding about my posting this late.)
Love the phrase : romantic sweeps up and down the keys. I believe your talent will see you published — just don’t give up. That notion hits all of us sooner or later. Shake that unwanted visitor off as soon as you can. Come check out my latest post if you’re of a mind.http://rolandyeomans.blogspot.com/.
Have a healing new month, Roland
Thanks very much, Roland! I appreciate the support. My path as a serious writer began almost five years ago, and I don’t see it changing course.
Great on both counts. I do believe I like the former the best, though. Fine work. Thanks for stopping by my blog!
Don’t mention it, Raquel! Thanks for taking a read. Yep, the second is a long-winded joke, really. I should put so much effort into every April Fool’s Day!
I have no idea. The second passage gave me a bit of a headache. I like tight focus.
Kinda prefer SF anyways, so I like the first version better. Simpler, and to the point. :)
Thanks for visiting, Andrew. The alt version is a headache to read, isn’t it? This guy never edited. Consequently, this wasn’t difficult to write, once I started thinking in semicolons and parentheses. Then I just left all my blathering in – no editing required. ;)
Editing is the toughest part, but it’s what makes our work readable!
I loved the hair mocking him in the second version– but I agree that the first version is stronger. I think you did a great job adopting a new style and following through, though, and that’s the point of this :) Good work!
Thanks, Amalia! I’ve never done an alt version anything, so I wanted to try something WAY different. Maybe too obscure – like a literary version of MST3K – but I had fun with it.
I added the hair-mocking when a friend (and BIG fan of this author) suggested adding an extra tangent or two. Definitely stream-of-consciousness, this guy…
Anyway, thanks for visiting, and for the thumbs-up (I love those!).
I’m not really big into alternate version-writing either– I think I’ve never done it for a real purpose. The closest I get is rewriting for revision purposes :)
Also, I have something for you on my blog today!
Ohmigosh, Amalia! Thanks for the Beautiful Blogger award. I’ll have to put that on my right rail (for more beauty, you know). Oh, and I love the exclamation point on my blog name. Maybe I’ll take that on permanently…
Love the facts about you. (Dogs that tremble make me sad, too.)
All in all, it was a good first experience with alt-versioning. I’d do it again! Maybe something a little easier on the eye next time.
Hi! Thanks for stopping by my blog and commenting on my alt. version scenes. Wow! You did a great job with this exercise. I loved the second version for it’s lit fic feel and period tone. I’m not sure of the author you aped, but I’d guess he wrote in the mid-1800s. It has the Melville/Austin/Eyre vibe.
My fave was, of course, your original scene. Best of luck with it and the rest of your WiP!
Thank you very much, Nicole! He was definitely of a different era – early 20th century, actually.
I’m glad you enjoyed it! It was a fun time (but yes, I’m partial to my original – haha).
Hi Margo,
I love the first version, but you have some gorgeous lines in the second–
I particularly love the “hands spanning octave-wide chords”, because one of my current pieces has me shifting an octave and an half on the keyboard, and I get so wound up about it!
I’d guess the second version is based on H.G. Wells, or maybe some of C.S. Lewis’ adult stuff, with Ransom. The run-on sentences are a little Dickensian, though, a la The Pickwick Papers.
I’d love to hear more about your WIP!
Oh goodness, Peta, thank you so much!
I like “fabricated melodrama” myself. I’m glad you enjoyed reading it. I love the freedom of the stream-of-consciousness style, but if this were my WIP I’d edit a ton out. :)
You’re close on the author, just not snooty enough – heh. I’ll probably email you lovely commenters with the answer.
I’d love to tell you about Thirty Decibels!
Short answer: Ava is turning fifteen amidst a two-class struggle in a future society. She breaks the rules before realizing her power to change them.
It’s eco-dystopia/social sci-fi. The more oppressed class speaks only in whispers, hence my title. The writing focuses on the characters, complete with family and teen struggles. My goal is a kid-friendly perspective on coming of age in an increasingly politically charged climate.
Hee, hee, that was a lot.
How about you? I’m so impressed with your blog. How do you do it? It can be tough to write ANYTHING with a little one in tow (my guy’s 18 months). You make it seem so easy, Peta!
Hi Margo! Thanks for your comment on my Alternate Blogfest entry. I’m very glad you left it because I’m glad for the chance to read yours. What gorgeous detail and light touch you give to heavy moments. I was going to guess Dickens for the latter one too, but I see that isn’t right.
Of course I prefer the first version and “deft fingers fluttered in romantic sweeps up and down the keys” is just wonderful. I also love, “the boy who stands to my right, who laughs and smiles in all the best ways, at all the best times, like someone with whom I could sit and enjoy a cup of lime-flower tea when we’re 80.”
Please do email with the answer!
Jen, you’re seriously making me blush. Seriously!
Hey, if some of you think it’s Dickensian, I can’t deny you. I’m SO happy with that comparison. Who wouldn’t be!? (Talk about a “happy accident.”)
It tickles me that you mentioned the lime-flower tea reference. That came from the original piece whose author I took inspiration from!
[Commence the google search! – especially if you want the answer sooner than, say, Friday…?]
I figured it out! But I see I’m not the first. Ah well. Great scene, and great puzzle :)
Jen, it’s quite alright! As I’d mentioned, I didn’t hunker down and read the guy until last week – so I probably wouldn’t have gotten it, either… Next time, next time. Thanks again for stopping in!
(I love your blog, BTW. I’ve posted a bit on the library crisis myself. Very disheartening – especially that the increase in patron visits last year doesn’t seem to matter to decision-makers.)
Margo,
Outstanding! I love it. I’m going to have to go with James Joyce for the alternate version.
Cheers,
Tim Keeton
Poet/Wizard/Teller-of-tales
Again, I’m absolutely blushing! But no. So close, SO close, Tim!
Hmm…well then, I suppose I would have to say Faulkner, but I would be surprised that you had not read him before now.
Sorry again, Tim! Academics-wise, I believe this guy is usually only part lit-degree curricula. I’d heard about him but never took the plunge until last week. Another hint: Reading his signature opus would take a long, long time (but you could assume that from the style)…
Proust?
DING, DING, DING!
We have a WINNER!
Thanks, Peta!
I don’t suppose you’d like to come to James Kennedy’s Dome of Doom event on 4/17 in Chicago, eh…? I’ll pay your admission, and even treat you to dinner beforehand! :)
Proust, eh? I have to admit, I haven’t read anything of his, either…so maybe I should!
As so many others said, lovely details. How fun that you took inspiration from another author! Sorry it took so long for me to comment back. :)
No worries at all, Sarah – thanks for visiting my blog. I appreciate your comment very much, whether you post it now or in a year!
I’m curious whether you’ll continue to explore zombies in your work… your humor suits them!
Why, thanks! You know, I never thought I would say this…but I think I might! It was fun, and I liked keeping it sort of tongue-in-cheek. What lovely things this alt fic fest has granted us! :)
Sarah, when you’re a famous zombie/humor writer be sure to give me a shout-out!
Phew, sorry it’s taken me so long to come back here! I’ve been swamped with work and baby – I think Mir’s starting in on the separation anxiety in his sleep again. Every night for the past three I’ve been woken up by a thrashing, crying baby!
Ah, Margo, I wish I could come by! It sounds like a lot of fun! Alas, IL & MA are too far apart. Chicago is on my list of places to try and visit before I eventually move back home (Australia), though.
Thanks for the kind words about my blog. It is hard to keep up with everything! I try and think of blogging, writing, and running as me time that I can’t do without–blogging helps me empty out the thoughts forever crowding my head–so I can take better care of Baby. I probably shouldn’t need the justification, but if it works, it works!
Peta, do let me know the next time you’ll be in Chicago!
You RUN, too? Gah, I’m so so jealous. I’m unofficially neglecting gym- and track-going until I’ve made my first submissions. For a while, I didn’t realize I was doing it!
Keep on truckin’, Peta. But we should both remember to take a break every now and then. Feels weird, but works wonders.